BGT - MCG Test - Yashasvi Jaiswal's controversial catch decision - out or not out?

India’s opening batsman Yashasvi Jaiswal He was given out in unusual circumstances during the final session on the fifth day of the Boxing Day Test at the MCG, when an on-field not-out decision for a caught-back was overturned by the third umpire, despite available technology confirming the edge. There wasn’t enough to do. ,

Jaiswal, batting on 84, attempted to hook a bouncer from Pat Cummins, the ball was caught by wicketkeeper Alex Carey, the Australians appealed, on-field umpire Joel Wilson called not-out, and Australia decided Reviewed.

While in real time the snicko showed a flat line as the ball passed the bat, regular replays showed a larger deflection. The third umpire Sharfuddaula went by what he saw – a deflection – and overturned the decision in Australia’s favour. Jaiswal was seen talking to the umpires before leaving. His dismissal meant that India’s last hope of saving the Test was also gone. Chasing a target of 340, they were left reeling at 140 for 7 and eventually lost by 184 runs.

Simon Taufel The third umpire agreed, saying that the deflection was “conclusive evidence”.

“In my view, the decision has been made,” Teufel said. channel 7“The third umpire took the right decision in the end. With the technology protocol, we have a hierarchy of redundancies and when the umpire sees a clear deflection from the bat there is no need to go ahead and use another type of case.” Technology to prove. Clear deflection is conclusive evidence.

“In this particular case, what we have seen from the third umpire is that he has used a secondary form of technology, which for whatever reason has not shown the same conclusive evidence as audio to support a clear deflection. “In the end, the third umpire did the right thing and went back on the apparent deflection and overturned the umpire’s zone, so in my view the right decision was taken.”

On live broadcast on Star Sports, Mark Nicholls and Sanjay Manjrekar called it a “courageous” decision by the third umpire.

“With Jaiswal out, I think it’s very brave of the third umpire to override the snick,” Nicholls said. “I think that’s also very rare.”

Manjrekar said, “These are not the best angles, given an angle that was in front, and that’s where you see the deflection when you look at it visually, you see the snicko which reaffirms everything. No The other umpire would have gone, well, if Snicko wasn’t showing it – and I like Snicko as a technique – then I’m not going to give it too, it would have been accepted by us.

“I don’t know if there are any other umpires, I mean I guess it goes with both bat and glove, it’s a total guess,” Nicholls said. “I think that’s the problem with watching that replay. Or that’s the problem with watching any other replay.”

Source link